Clove Tom Collins Pie Screenshot

Clove Tom Collins Pie

I have been avoiding the Clove Tom Collins Pie recipe for a while, for obvious reasons. Ladies and gentlemen, I’ve tried Bubble Crum, Salad with Mustard and Ketchup and Boiled Celery and I can say, without hyperbole, that this is a million times worse than all of them put together.

In this so-called recipe Homer first uses Tom Collins Mix, which doesn’t really exist. A classic Tom Collins cocktail is made up of gin, sour mix, soda, and simple syrup, so I used limonade for this pie and declared it close enough. Also not available are pie crust TOPS – which is what it looks like Homers uses. Obviously pie crust bottoms can be found in any frozen food aisle. And if you just turn them upside down they turn into pie crust tops. Easy as pie (see what I did there?). However, in the interest of not wasting an entire pie crust I used a tart shell instead.


  • Cloves
  • Tom Collins Mix (Limonade)
  • Frozen Pie Crust (tart shell)


Add cloves and Tom Collins mix to frozen pie crust. Take a single bite and immediately regret all the decisions in your life leading up to this moment.


Going in I knew this was going to be bad, I mean cloves are basically inedible but the frozen pie crust mixed with any kind of liquid becomes a mushy mess within about 10 seconds. This was bad. Really, really, really, bad.

Cromulence: 0 Gamblors out of 10

Clove Tom Collins Pie Recipe From: $pringfield (Or, How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love Legalized Gambling) (The Simpsons Season 5 – Episode 10)







10 Responses to “Clove Tom Collins Pie”

  1. Cenzo Avatar

    “0 Gamblors out of 10”

    You’ve embiggened this abomination of a dish with your cromulent rating!

    1. Eats Like A Duck Avatar
      Eats Like A Duck

      The only monster here is the gambling monster that has enslaved your mother! I call him Gamblor, and it’s time to snatch your mother from his neon claws!

  2. Jon Avatar

    My wife and I are crying reading these. Thank you

    1. Eats Like A Duck Avatar
      Eats Like A Duck

      Glad you enjoy! If you’ve learned anything from this blog (and I’m sure you haven’t) it’s don’t eat whole cloves for breakfast.

  3. Hugh Jass Avatar
    Hugh Jass

    I remember researching each of these ingredients many years ago (since I don’t think I’ve had any of them separately) and realized this was probably the grossest “meal” the writers could come up with. Sounds like it belongs in a dumpster, or at least a Trash-Co waste disposal unit. Homer’s eyes in the screenshot say it all.

    1. Eats Like A Duck Avatar
      Eats Like A Duck

      Exactly. If Homer can’t even stomach eating something that you know it’s really, really, really bad. I guess the lesson here is, whole spices were not mean to be consumed with alcohol mixers and pie crust.

    1. Eatslikeaduck Avatar

      Good to know! But I don’t think my stomach can handle eating straight cloves again, so I might not re-make this breakfast recipe.

  4. Amelia Avatar

    Ever since I watched this episode I wanted to know what that would have tasted like. Awful is the word it seems. Nonetheless this blog is making me cry with laughter, the dry humour way in which it’s written just tickles me. 1000% better than Buzzfeed.

    1. Eatslikeaduck Avatar

      Glad you’re enjoying the blog! I like to think of my humor as “Vintage Simpsons-esque”…also please never attempt to recreate Clove Tom Collins Pie. Just don’t.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *